The Whiskey Barrel Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to The Whiskey Barrel, an inviting gem located at 138 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY. This vibrant establishment offers a carefully curated selection of whiskeys, craft beers, and delectable dishes that promise to delight your palate. Casual yet sophisticated, the menu features whiskey flights like the Irish Goodbye and the Top Shelf selection, perfect for whiskey enthusiasts looking to explore rich flavors.

For those craving a filling meal, diners rave about the substantial burgers, pulled pork, and chicken wraps that are sure to satisfy any appetite. With attentive service and a cozy atmosphere, The Whiskey Barrel has become a cherished spot for locals. Customers have described their experiences as delightful, praising both the knowledgeable staff and the warm ambiance that enhances every visit.

Whether stopping by for drinks or a hearty meal, The Whiskey Barrel is a must-visit destination that captures the spirit of community and culinary excellence.

Suggested Flights Craft Beer Flight Create Your Own

Suggested Flights

Sweet Village (pick 3)

Brown Sugar Bourbon • Montauk Blueberry Whiskey • Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey • Jack Daniel's Tennessee Honey
US$16.00

Michter, Michter (pick 3)

Michter's Straight Bourbon • Michter's Sour Mash • Michter's Unblended Small Batch • Michter's Rye Single Barrel
US$22.00

The White Knight

Pugliese Vineyards Pinot Grigio • Josh Chardonnay • Oyster Bay Sauvignon Blanc
US$20.00

"I'm Seeing Red!"

Pugliese Cabernet • Josh Pinot Noir • The Lost Chapters Merlot
US$20.00

Our Most Popular Pours

Angel's Envy Bourbon • Basil Hayden's Bourbon • Bulleit Bourbon
US$23.00

Irish Goodbye

Green Spot Irish Whiskey • The Tyrconnell 10yr Irish Whiskey • Writers Tears Copper Pot Irish Whiskey
US$23.00

"I've Got Proof!"

Old Forester 1920 - 115 proof • Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye - 112.2 proof • Old Ezra Brooks 7yr Barrel Str - 117 proof
US$28.00

The George Thorogood

Eagle Rare Bourbon • Glenmorangie 18yr Scotch • Draft Beer of Your Choice
US$31.00

On The Top Shelf

Stagg Jr • Widow Jane "The Vaults" 15yr • Michters Barrel Strength Rye
US$47.00

WhistlePig Trio

WhistlePig 10yr Rye • WhistlePig 12yr Rye • WhistlePig 15yr Rye
US$57.00

Craft Beer Flight

Choose Any 4 Draft Beers from Our Menu Varies

Craft Beer Flight

Create Your Own

Create Your Own

Choose Any Whiskey, Beer, or Wine - Mix and Match Varies